BaubleBar has been in my jewelry rotation for over 10 years, and I’ve linked their pieces in more outfit posts than any other jewelry brand. But I’ve never sat down and written about the custom line specifically, which is a little funny, because it’s what people ask me about most.
Personalized jewelry is one of those things that looks great in a product photo and can go one of two ways in real life. Either it becomes the thing you wear every day, or the plating wears off by March, and it lives in a drawer. I wanted to know which camp each of these falls into, and the only way to answer that is to actually wear them.
So that’s what this is. Four pieces, real wear, and an honest answer on whether each one is worth the money. And, okay, one of them isn’t a jewelry piece, but it’s something I use daily.
The quick verdict
If you only read this part:
- The Custom Tennis Bracelet is the one worth buying. It’s the piece I reach for most, and it’s the one my readers buy most too.
- Order early for gifts. Custom pieces are made to order, so they ship slower than everything else on the site. When I checked in early October, a custom bracelet ordered that day was set to ship 16 days later. Expect that to stretch as the holidays get closer.
- The custom accessories are better gifts than the jewelry if you don’t know someone’s taste. A tote or laptop sleeve with their initials is hard to get wrong.
- If you’re late, skip custom entirely and buy an initial piece that’s already made. More on that below.
Quick compare
| Piece | What I use it for | Price | Worth it? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Custom Tennis Bracelet | Daily wear, stacks with everything | $78 | Yes, my top pick |
| Custom Alpha Tote | A roomy tote great for weekend trips | $78 | Yes, as a gift |
| Custom laptop sleeve | To protect my laptop every time it leaves my home | $48 | Yes, under $50 gift |
| Mini Semi-Precious Custom Necklace | On-trend accessory and a pop of color | $58 | As a gift, yes |

The Custom Tennis Bracelet
This is the one. If you’re going to buy a single custom BaubleBar piece, buy this.
It’s a classic gold pavé tennis bracelet with your letters set into it, so from across the room it reads as a regular tennis bracelet and up close it says something. That’s the whole appeal for me. It doesn’t scream “monogram,” and it stacks with everything else I own without fighting it.
How it’s held up: Candidly, some of my Baublebar pieces have tarnished over time, but this one has held up surprisingly well. I don’t wear it in the shower and remove it before bed. This piece will last for years.
Sizing: Three sizes are available: 6.75 (standard), 6.15, and 7.15. The standard size is fairly small, so keep the recipient’s wrist size in mind when ordering.
It’s also the custom piece my readers buy most. I’ll take that as a sign I’m not the only one who thinks it’s the best of the line.
Who it’s for: anyone who wants personalized jewelry that still looks like real jewelry. It’s the safest gift on this list.

The Custom Alpha Tote
I didn’t expect to love a tote this much. My Custom Alpha Tote is in Butter Yellow, and I like to bring my bag to photo shoots, farmers’ markets, and weekend trips. It can fit a lot, and it’s also super adorable.
The letters are the fun part. You pick them, and they read as playful instead of precious, which is exactly what you want on a bag you throw in the back seat.
I think this is a better gift than the jewelry for most people. You don’t need to know someone’s ring size or whether they wear gold or silver. You just need to know their initials.
Who it’s for: the friend who’s impossible to shop for, a bridesmaid gift, or anyone who’d use a good everyday tote.
Sizing: Three sizes are available, and the bag pictured above is a size large.

The custom laptop sleeve and pouch
I was gifted the Clocked In Custom Laptop Sleeve last year, and I use it regularly. This is the sleeper pick. It’s not the thing anyone puts on a wishlist, but it’s the thing you use every day, and seeing your name on your laptop case is a small, nice thing.
I travel a lot for work, and it’s survived airport security bins and plenty of wear and tear. The only thing it hasn’t survived is my cat’s teeth (side note: why are kitties so obsessed with neoprene?) Overall, this is an incredibly thoughtful pick, and one of the more useful gifts you can give.
Who it’s for: coworkers, grads, anyone who works from a coffee shop.

The Mini Semi-Precious Custom Necklace
Out of all the custom jewelry pieces from Baublebar that I own, this necklace is the most fun. I love that it comes in multiple colors, so you can choose something refined or vibrant. The price is also fantastic: this necklace is only $58, and if there’s a sitewide sale, you can snag it for even less.
Who it’s for: your most stylish friends.
How custom ordering works (and the holiday cutoff)
This is the part that trips people up, so read it before you order a gift.
Custom pieces are made to order. That means they take longer to ship than BaubleBar’s regular stock, and they have their own holiday deadline that comes earlier than the site’s standard shipping cutoff.
- Production time: About two weeks before it ships, plus delivery. When I checked in early October, a custom bracelet ordered that day was set to ship 16 days later. Expect that to stretch as the holidays get closer.
- Holiday order-by date for custom: Last year, custom orders placed on Black Friday still arrived by Christmas. I wouldn’t push it any later than that. Ordering early also means you won’t be refreshing the tracking page on December 20th.
- Returns: Custom items are final sale. Make sure your spelling is correct.
My rule: if it’s a gift, order custom before Thanksgiving, for your own peace of mind.

Running late? Buy an initial piece instead
If you’ve missed the custom cutoff, BaubleBar’s initial pieces get you most of the way there without the wait. They’re made ahead and sold by the letter, so they ship like regular stock.
The one I’d point you to is the Dangle Charm Initial Pisa Bracelet. It’s a stretch bracelet with a single pavé initial charm, and it’s one of my most-worn BaubleBar pieces, custom or not. The Pavé Pisa Bracelet is its plainer sister and stacks right next to it. Neither one says “I forgot until the last minute.” These items aren’t water-resistant, so take them off in the shower.
Shop My Top Baublebar Custom Picks:
What’s Not Pictured + What I haven’t tried (yet)
BaubleBar’s custom line goes well beyond jewelry now. They offer custom ornaments and phone cases that are very popular, but I don’t own any, so I’m not going to review them. If I end up with one this season, I’ll add it here.
I do have a personalized blanket from BaubleBar, and I am really impressed with the quality. Most options are under $100; they’re soft, a great weight, and feel much more expensive than they are. For the girl who loves to cozy up on the couch, this is a great pick.
So, is BaubleBar custom worth it?
For the tennis bracelet, yes, easily. It’s the piece I’d buy again, and the one I’d give without overthinking it.
For the accessories, also yes, and I’d argue they’re the smarter gift for anyone whose jewelry taste you don’t know.
The only piece I wouldn’t recommend is the Custom Cord Bracelet. I’ve tried a couple of different versions of it and found it flimsy, but everything else I’ve tried is a winner. If you’re worried about tarnishing, I’d opt for the 14k gold options they offer, or stick to accessories.
FAQ
Is BaubleBar custom jewelry real gold?
Most custom BaubleBar jewelry is made with gold-plated brass, but a few options are 14K gold.
How long does BaubleBar custom take to ship?
Custom pieces are made to order, so they take longer than regular stock. The current production time is about two weeks. For holiday gifts, order before Thanksgiving.
Can you return BaubleBar custom jewelry?
No. Custom items are final sale.
Does BaubleBar custom jewelry tarnish?
I can’t speak for all of the jewelry, but the tennis bracelet has held up well over the years. I would not recommend showering with any BaubleBar custom pieces. If you’re worried about tarnishing, I would opt for the 14k gold options.
What’s the best BaubleBar custom gift?
The Custom Tennis Bracelet for someone who wears jewelry, and the Custom Alpha Tote or the Laptop Sleeve for someone whose taste you don’t know.
If you liked this post, check out:
















Leave a Reply